Do Expensive Skincare Products Actually Work Better?
Expensive doesn’t always mean better—here’s how to tell when a skincare product is actually worth the investment.
Do Expensive Skincare Products Actually Work Better?
I get asked this all the time: Is expensive skincare actually better?
The answer is… sometimes. A higher price tag doesn’t automatically mean a better product, but there are certain things that genuinely cost more to formulate well. So, I’m breaking down the questions I get asked most often about when skincare is worth the splurge—and when you may just be paying for a pretty jar.
1. Generally speaking, what sets an expensive anti-aging face cream apart from an affordable one?
Lower-priced creams are often designed for mass-market distribution — meaning they’re created to be safe for millions of people who might buy them off a drugstore shelf without any professional guidance. The bigger the audience, the greater the liability risk of someone misusing the product. To protect themselves, companies keep the concentrations of active ingredients very low. That makes the cream safe for almost everyone, but often too weak to deliver meaningful anti-aging results.
Luxury department-store creams are still mass-market products, which means they also tend to use low concentrations of active ingredients for liability reasons. The difference is that, instead of keeping the cost down, more of the money goes into the “experience” of the product — the luxurious packaging, the texture, the fragrance, and the prestige of the brand name. They can feel wonderful to use, but they oftentimes aren’t a ton more effective than lower-priced mass-market products.
Where price is more likely to reflect performance is in "medical-grade" skincare, which is typically available through medical practices, under a medical provider's supervision. These products are usually on the higher end price-wise because they’re formulated with higher concentrations of proven actives in advanced, stable delivery systems — strong enough to create visible, measurable changes in the skin. And yes, that also means there’s a higher chance of irritation if they’re used incorrectly. But because they’re dispensed under medical supervision, there’s less concern about liability and more focus on achieving results. In other words, medical-grade products are able to prioritize efficacy over mass-market safety — and that’s where you tend to see the biggest results. Plus, when you purchase through a medical office, there’s always someone on staff you can directly reach out to if you’re having issues with a product — something you’d never get when grabbing a cream off a drugstore shelf.
2. Is the expensive option really more effective than the affordable option in most cases?
Where cost is more likely to translate into results is with medical-grade skincare. These products are usually more expensive because they’re formulated with higher concentrations of proven ingredients, in stable formulations that cost more to produce, and paired with advanced delivery systems that are also more expensive to develop. They’re typically backed by testing to support their claims, which is another layer of investment. It’s that combination of concentration, stability, delivery, and evidence — not just the price tag — that makes them more effective.
3. How can you tell if an expensive product is “worth” it or not?
One of the top things to look for is transparency around percentages of proven active ingredients. If a brand is highlighting a hero ingredient but not disclosing how much of it is in the formula, that’s often a red flag. A great example is Neutrogena® Rapid Tone Repair Retinol + Vitamin C Correcting Cream. It promotes vitamin C and retinol as key actives, yet nowhere on the website or packaging are the percentages listed. A quick look at the ingredient list shows retinol near the very end — meaning it’s likely present at an extremely low, almost negligible concentration.
Another example is Olay Regenerist Retinol 24 Night Face Cream Moisturizer, which markets retinol as a star ingredient without disclosing the percentage either. The bottom line: if a brand is proud of their percentages, they’ll share them — because efficacy depends on it.
But here’s the catch: just because a product contains a high concentration of an ingredient doesn’t make it automatically effective. Take vitamin C, for example. You could have a formula boasting 20% L-ascorbic acid, but vitamin C is notoriously unstable. If it’s not paired with proper stabilizers and delivered through an effective delivery system that ensures penetration into the skin, that 20% won’t matter because it can degrade or oxidize long before it benefits your skin. Creating a formula that maintains stability and has the right delivery mechanism is complex and costly — which is why you don't see it in a $15 serum. In my opinion, vitamin C is one of those products where you truly get what you pay for.
Another thing to check is ingredient order. Cosmetic ingredient lists are required to be listed in descending order by concentration. So if the “hero” ingredient being advertised — like retinol, vitamin C, or peptides — appears at the very bottom, it’s probably included in such a tiny amount that it’s unlikely to deliver real results. This is a common marketing tactic: the brand can legally claim the ingredient is in the formula, but the concentration is so low it’s essentially just for show. If you see water, emollients, and fillers dominating the first half of the list and the key active buried in the last few spots, that’s a sign the product’s claims probably don't match its performance.
At the end of the day, you do not need the most expensive version of every product in your routine. I would much rather see you invest in a few well-formulated products that are actually creating change in your skin than spend hundreds of dollars on something because the jar looks beautiful on your bathroom counter.
Price doesn't equal performance. Formulation does.
With love,
Blair
Is September Really the Worst Month for Hair Shedding?
Why does it feel like your hair is suddenly shedding in early fall? We’re breaking down the science behind seasonal hair shedding—and what you can do to support your scalp...
How Long Should You Really Wait Between Skincare Steps?
You really don’t need to wait five minutes between every step of your skincare routine. Here’s when a few seconds is plenty—and the few times giving your products a little...
How to Get Rid of Blackheads Fast
Wondering how to get rid of blackheads? Learn what causes them, what actually works, and the skincare ingredients that keep pores clear.