Do You Actually Need an Eye Cream (or Is It a Total Scam?)
I’m breaking down when an eye cream is just clever marketing, when it truly earns its spot in your routine, and how to tell the difference—so you can stop guessing...
Do You Actually Need an Eye Cream (or Is It a Total Scam?)
I’m going to say something mildly controversial for someone who literally sells eye cream. Some of them are pointless. There. I said it.
Not all. But enough that I understand why people side-eye that tiny $100 jar with skepticism. The question isn’t “are eye creams a scam?,” – it’s “how do you differentiate a good eye cream from one that’s just clever marketing?”
Yes, there are eye creams that are basically diluted moisturizer in a smaller jar with a bigger price tag. If the ingredient list is identical to the brand’s face cream, just repackaged, that’s a red flag. You’re paying for marketing.
Why the eye area is different
The skin around your eyes really is different. Thinner (about 40% thinner than the rest of your face, actually). More delicate. And fewer oil glands, which means it dries out faster and shows signs of aging earlier. So yes — dehydration, irritation, and collagen loss show up there first. But that doesn’t automatically mean you need a separate product. This is where formulation really matters.
Yes, there are eye creams that are basically diluted moisturizer in a smaller jar with a bigger price tag. If the ingredient list is identical to the brand’s face cream, just repackaged, that’s a red flag. You’re paying for marketing.
When eye creams earn their place
But when an eye cream is formulated well, the ingredient strategy shifts. They’re not treating thick cheek skin – they’re specifically built for thin, vascular skin prone to puffiness, dark circles, dehydration, and crepiness. And certain ingredients that don’t make much sense for the full face suddenly make a lot of sense for the eyes.
For instance, arnica.
If someone tried to sell you an arnica-based full-face cream for anti-aging, I’d raise an eyebrow. Arnica is primarily useful for bruising and vascular support. It’s not a classic collagen‑building or pigment‑correcting ingredient that you’d use for your entire face. But under the eyes? Where darkness is often vascular — meaning you’re literally seeing blood vessels through thin skin — arnica makes a lot of sense and can be really helpful in combatting dark circles.
Same with caffeine.
Caffeine on your whole face isn’t doing much in terms of skin benefits - which is why it's rarely even included in them. But under the eyes, where puffiness is often fluid retention and sluggish microcirculation, caffeine becomes much more relevant for improving under eye bags and puffiness.
And peptides are where it gets even more interesting. Not all peptides are created equal – some target the eye area's constant micro-contractions from squinting and blinking. Take Dipeptide Diaminobutyroyl Benzylamide Diacetate (DDBD), a topical Botox-like neuropeptide for crow's feet. You won't find it as a star ingredient in most face creams because it’s not trying to remodel your entire face. But around eyes, where thin skin shows every etched line first, it makes perfect strategic sense.
The Bottom Line
So, are eye creams worth it? The honest answer is: sometimes. Instead of asking “should I be using an eye cream,” ask yourself “what do I want this product to actually do?” If your answer is vague — something like “because I’m supposed to” — you might not need one. If your answer is specific — “I want less morning puffiness,” “my dark circles drive me nuts,” or “my concealer is always catching on crepey lines”— then a well-designed eye cream (like this one) with targeted ingredients can absolutely earn its place in your routine.
How Often Should I Exfoliate (Without Overdoing It)?
Exfoliation is often treated like an extra step in your routine — but it’s actually a process your skin is already doing on its own. We're breaking down how skin...
Why Your Skin Is Red (and How to Soothe It)
Redness doesn’t just “happen.” It’s often your skin’s way of asking for a pause. From inflammation to overdoing actives, we’re breaking down the most common causes — and how to...
Is Your Nighttime Skincare Routine Missing This Key Step?
Most of us have a solid routine for our face — cleansers, serums, moisturizers — but our lips? They’re the step we skip without realizing it. We’re unpacking why lip...